<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">
Digitální knihovna UPCE přechází na novou verzi. Omluvte prosím případné komplikace. / The UPCE Digital Library is migrating to a new version. We apologize for any inconvenience.

Moral Attention and Bad Sentimentality

ArticleRestrictedpeer-reviewedpostprint
Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Date

relationships.isAuthorOf

Thesis advisor

Referee

Journal Title

Volume Title

Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, I challenge standard views of the moral badness of sentimentality defended by art critics and philosophers. Accounts based on untruthfulness and self-indulgence lack the resources to both explain the badness of bad sentimentality and to allow that there are benign instances. We are sometimes permitted to be sentimental even though it is self-serving. A non-moralistic account should allow for this. To provide such an account, I first outline a substantive view of the ideal of unsentimentality by turning to Rainer Maria Rilke’s Letters on Cézanne. Rilke celebrates the artist for his unsentimental love of his subjects and “untiring objective wakefulness” to them. I then turn to Iris Murdoch’s ethics of attention (itself influenced by Rilke) to explain why this ideal is so difficult to live up to in practice, the various ways that we fall short, and what our failures mean. What Murdoch contributes is both a sense that the lovingly attentive attitude that Rilke describes is morally—and not just artistically—important and a compassionate account of the human egocentrism that inhibits it. By thinking of sentimentality as a failure of moral attention, we can appreciate how particular instances differ from one another. Sentimentality can console us in difficult times or can gratify our egos; it can be a form of escapism or can rigidly enclose reality; and it can be harmlessly self-serving or a selfish failure to morally attend to the other when it counts. I conclude by outlining some ways that being seen with Cézanne-like moral attention can matter to us.

Pages

p. 315-336

ISSN

1382-4554

Project

EH22_008/0004595/Za hranice bezpečnosti: role konfliktu v posilování odolnosti

Is Part of

Journal of Ethics, volume 2025, issue: 29

Related Resources

E-version Access

Pouze v rámci univerzity

Conference Name

ISBN

Study Specialization

Study Programme

Library Call Number

Printed Version Location

Printed Version Access Rights

Keywords

Iris Murdoch, Rilke, ethics of attention, sentimentality, philosophy of love, paternalism, Iris Murdoch, Rilke, etika pozornosti, sentimentalita, filozofie lásky, paternalismus

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By